In Defense of the Movie You'd Never Put in Your Top Four
Photo: Miguel Pires da Rosa from Braga, Portugal, CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons
Ask a room of people to name their four favorite films and you'll get four hundred very good, very defensible answers and about three true ones.
I say this as someone with a Letterboxd account, a Criterion bookmark, and a genuinely held opinion about the 1970s. I'm not above it. But the top four is a resume. It's the version of your taste that has been edited for the group project. And every time I see a list that could have been assembled by a film studies department, I want to ask the person what they put on when they're home sick.
Because that answer — the sick-day movie, the one you've seen thirty times, the one you would never put on a list — is doing far more work than any of the respectable ones.
Your Taste Has a Childhood
The movies you loved before you knew what was cool are basically a fingerprint. They came in through the side door: the one your mom left on cable all afternoon, the VHS your cousin taped off TV with the commercials still in, the one your dad fell asleep to every Sunday with his glasses on.
You didn't choose it because it was good. You chose it because it was there, and you were eleven, and something in it made the world feel manageable. That's not a lapse in judgment. That's a record of who you were.
The film critic's version of taste asks, is this well made? The human version asks, what did this do to me, and when?
The Top Four Is a Resume
We've built an entire infrastructure around performing taste. Star ratings. Watchlists arranged like a thesis. The four-poster grid that functions as a public statement of identity, carefully curated the way you'd curate a bookshelf visible from the doorway.
There's a tell in the numbers, if you look: five stars for the film you admire, four and a half for the one you've actually rewatched eleven times. We've quietly agreed that admiration ranks above affection. That being impressed is a higher compliment than being comforted.
It isn't. Ask anyone who's been through a bad year.
Snobbery Is Just Fear in a Nice Jacket
Calling something a guilty pleasure is a way of pre-paying for a defense you haven't been asked to make. The guilt isn't about the movie. It's about the audience you imagine watching you watch it.
And cultural snobbery — real snobbery, the reflexive kind — is boring in a very specific way. It's fear wearing a nice jacket. It's the person who says 'I don't really watch movies' and then has a strong opinion about one Marvel title. It's the phrase 'elevated horror,' which mostly means the same movie with worse lighting and better press.
Being unembarrassed is more interesting than being correct. That's not a hot take. That's just what it's like to talk to someone at a party who isn't managing you.
What Your Uncool Favorite Actually Knows
Here's the part that gets overlooked. The embarrassing favorite isn't just nostalgia. It's a thesis.
National Treasure is a movie about a man who believes something ridiculous in public, without a shred of irony, and is eventually proven right. Twister is about people who drive toward the thing everyone else is running from. Mamma Mia! is about a woman who built a whole life out of other people's messes and then sang about it. The Parent Trap — either version, be honest — is about wanting a family so badly you'd engineer it yourself.
None of those are subtle. All of them are sincere. And sincerity is the thing we're most starved of, in a culture that rewards the ironic distance of not caring.
The movie you put on after a breakup is never an aesthetic choice. It's a prescription. That's worth noticing.
Sincerity Is the Real Flex
There's a version of this essay that would tell you to just own it, love what you love, hashtag joy. That's not quite it. The point isn't that all movies are secretly great. Some of them are genuinely bad, and loving a bad movie is allowed.
The point is that taste is autobiography, and autobiography isn't supposed to be flattering. It's supposed to be accurate.
So here's a small experiment. The next time someone asks for your top four, put one uncool favorite in the number three slot. Don't justify it. Don't lead with 'I know this is kind of a guilty pleasure, but.' Just say it and stop talking.
Watch what happens. The wrong people will smirk. The right people will lean in and ask a follow-up question — usually about the scene they love too. That's the whole sorting mechanism, and it costs you nothing but a little pride.
A Permission Slip
You are allowed to be a person with a personality instead of a person with a ranking system.
The film you'd never put on a list has been with you longer than most of your friendships. It knows what you needed at fourteen and what you still need on a Sunday afternoon in November. That's not a weakness in your taste. That's the taste. Everything else is just cataloging.